Reviews completed awaiting final decision meaning. Then, it changed to ‘Pending Editor prelim decision.

Reviews completed awaiting final decision meaning Awaiting Decision Nov 17, 2023 · Awaiting allocation: The editorial team is assigning the paper to suitable reviewers; Under review: Two or more expert reviewers are currently reviewing the manuscript; Final decision: The editor has received the peer review reports and has made a final decision; Possible Decisions Per Muhammad Ali 's response, I respectfully disagree that any review process should take over a year. It is a software issue or a bug. Considering this, I would like to know what factors often delay the final decision on a manuscript. Some examples include “editor assigned” “reviewers invited” “under review” “review complete” “decision pending,” and others. Oct 9, 2020 · I had sent an article to an SCIE journal using the ScholarOne manuscript system. Indeed, the change of status is promising, but I think following up with the editor on when the reviews will be complete is reasonable in this case. However, the short period of time since submission seems to suggest that this is a rapid publication journal or that the peer review was done internally (in case the journal had the requisite expertise). 6. Jan 25, 2017 · The reviews have been completed and the system administrator or the journal manager assigned the editor (who is assumed to be associated with it earlier) to take care of the review reports and make a call. " I checked the status recently and it has changed to "awaiting final decision. Now, it shows Awaiting Decision. After two more days the status changed to "Under Review. After subsequent changes in the status, finally it showed “Reviews completed” on 5th of July. May 1, 2021 · The status “awaiting final decision after awaiting reviewer scores” means that the peer review has been completed and the reviewer comments have been sent back to the editorial office for assessment. I have not been asked for a revision. The number of review reports is not sufficient. The paper received an R&R last summer and a revised version was provided. But how does the editor actually take the decision on a manuscript? This article explains the sequence of events that lead from peer review to editorial decision making: how the AE procures the completed reviews, assesses them, and finally comes to a decision on whether to accept the manuscript, request Nov 19, 2020 · The AE then conveys their decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), who makes the final decision the status is changed again (Awaiting decision), after 2 days, the status is changed again Jul 15, 2019 · It has been 1 month since I submitted an article to one of the leading journals in my field. The status said "reviews completed" (2 reviewers sent their reports). 4e: Awaiting publisher decision: Dove Editorial is discussing the final decision with the Editor No matter which decision you receive, be sure to read the entire decision letter carefully. The status reviews completed was Sep 11, 2020 · I submitted a manuscript to a Springer-based journal (3 Biotech) on June 3. Now, the status has changed to ‘Awaiting Admin Final Processing’ from ‘Awaiting EIC Decision. However, after reviewers completed their assignments, the authors do respond to May 14, 2015 · In Editorial Manager (EM) a submission is considered ready for decision when a certain number of reviews have been completed, based on the article type and optionally customized by an editor. At this stage, the editor is diligently analysing the feedback, weighing the merits and shortcomings of the manuscript, and is in the crucial phase of making a decision I submitted a manuscript that went through the entire peer review process. Decision in Process: This means that the editor is now taking a decision on your paper based on the peer reviewer comments and his/her own opinion. Then, two weeks later it switched back to "passed technical checks, now Aug 26, 2022 · BUT, if we decided the paper needed a third reviewer (e. For journals participating in the Journal Insights programme, you can get an idea of the expected review time of your journal. On September 21, I received an email from the editor stating the following. Apr 5, 2021 · Most journals typically take around 4-12 weeks to share their final decision. Indeed, as suggested in the comment (by Dirk), being polite is key. What does this mean? Oct 1, 2024 · Required Reviews Completed. The case I am making here is that when everything is completed some journal show "Required reviews Completed" others show "Decision in Progress. This usually happens if there are a lot of papers for which the reviews have already come in before yours. Jul 23, 2021 · This indicates the completion of the review process of your manuscript and AE will take the decision whether to reject, revise or accept (rare if it is first round). Sep 30, 2020 · I submitted a manuscript to an Elsevier journal on September 2. How should this double status be interpreted? Is the revised manuscript with the editor or reviewers, or both? Sep 30, 2019 · Across all Wolters Kluwer journals, the average time that a manuscript moves through the submission process from submission to first decision takes about 30 days, and to a final decision about 54 days, but this is dependent upon many factors and is different for each journal. Nov 25, 2024 · The Editors of potential receiving journals have agreed to view further detail about the manuscript and will complete a form either approving the manuscript for transfer or passing on the manuscript. Resubmit for Review: When the EIC takes the Resubmit for review decision from the dropdown list, the manuscript goes back to the Review process. Sep 15, 2021 · Hi, My manuscript is under the 3rd round of review, with R1 acceptance and R2 revision in the 2nd round. After three months of 'Under review', the status changed to 'Required review completed' a week ago, then it became 'With editor'. Does the status Decision in Process mean or imply a Reject decision in this case? May 25, 2020 · I submitted my paper in January. Email Templates I spent at least a few hours today digging through Slate documents and articles. Review Complete: Once an approval or exemption decision has been reached for a protocol and the IRB Office has signed off on it, this status becomes permanent for the submission and the Study Status may change to reflect it, as when an Initial Submission is first declared "Approved" or when an expired protocol finishes the continuing review process. After this process is complete, you will receive a decision from the Journal Editor regarding your manuscript, which is informed by recommendations from Reviewers. We sent two follow-up emails regarding the status of the manuscript in December. Related reading: How long does a revised paper remain at the 'Required reviews completed' status? Why is my paper repeatedly changing from "Required reviews completed" to "Under The peer review history package includes the complete editorial decision letter for each revision, with reviews, and your responses to reviewer comments, including attachments. Your article has been accepted and you will receive an email to confirm. This decision will be based on the Co-Editors-in-Chief’s own careful evaluation of the manuscript in conjunction with the decision made by the Editors. 18th of July, the status is showing “Editor assigned. The target number of required reviews has been completed, and the Handling Editor is considering the reviews. The previous Apr 17, 2024 · Background completed 27/8/23 Final decision:- 16/4/24 Approved Apart from final decision all those dates visible today itself till now only processing. Finally today, i. Also known as: with reviewers, with referees, under review, awaiting referee assignment, awaiting referee reports, awaiting reviewer scores, awaiting reviewer invitation , reviewers assigned, manuscript assigned to peer-reviewer/s (NPG) The initial selection of referees is usually comprised in the previous step. So, this might be a rapid-publication journal. Your application is being reviewed by the faculty admissions committee. " Required Reviews Complete: This status indicates that all peer reviews are completed and have been received by the editorial office. ’ Is this likely to be a rejection – or can I still expect an acceptance? Aug 3, 2023 · It might also be a temporary status while awaiting further reviews or clarification. Granted of course it’s possible that a decision simply wasn’t uploaded Dec 17, 2024 · Revised reviews will be completed in around three working days, considering that reviewers are already familiar with the content of your paper, but we are flexible if reviewers require more time. ” In case Aug 6, 2016 · Completed Reject: In case the author has made the revisions requested by the peer reviewers and editor, the final decision on the manuscript could be either “accept” or “reject. To me, it seems like they've made a decision but haven't released it yet. Upon acceptance, you may be asked to complete additional steps. Jul 8, 2015 · I submitted an article to springer. Any article submitted to any journal goes under review if found suitable and within the scope of that journal. Accept. Tracker still shows Eligibility not started, nor document number but passport almost got stamp today. For example, providing final high-quality files or signing a publishing agreement. * Revise Reviews completed: 2+ Review invitations accepted: 2+ Review invitations sent: 2+ Checking the submission status from the journal editorial system also showed "Required Reviews Completed" with the same date of 16th of April. Pay special attention to deadlines and next steps. I have no idea why this is the case, but it meant that some papers stay on 'Reviews Completed' for a long time as we are securing and waiting for a third review report before making a decision. all means the same thing- your application is complete, but a decision has yet to be made on your application. due to a split decision on the initial reviews), it NEVER changed back to 'Under Review'. The Editor will take into account the expert reviewers’ opinions to make an informed decision of accept, reject or revise. Seems like tracker is bit slow now. Jul 12, 2022 · On July 12 the status was Awaiting AE Assignment Awaiting EIC Decision Does it mean rejection? I submitted my paper on June 24 and after few comments from the admin on the paper files I resubmitted the paper. Sep 8, 2022 · Peer review is a crucial step through the process and since your process was run through double peer reviews, the amount of time taken could be justified. Feb 5, 2022 · I have a paper that was under review with one of Wiley's journals. After one week, I wrote to the Managing Editor enquiring about the status of my article, and he told me that he had received the needed reviews, and he is only waiting for the word of the Editor-in-Chief before he communicates the final Nov 21, 2022 · Awaiting a recommendation does mean nothing except waiting for decision-makers to accept it or review it. Or does this always mean you've made it to the next round of admissions and I'm overthinking it? A Subreddit dedicated to providing assistance & resources to anyone who is seeking information regarding SSA disability history & processes. (‘Referee’ is another I submitted an article in a scientific journal, after verification by the editor the status is changed (Awaiting Reviewer Scores), then after a month and a half, the status is changed again Peer Reviewer(s) second round completed: Revised manuscript and second round reviewer comments sent to Editor-in-Chief for final decision. You can expect the status to soon change to "Decison in process" and you will be conveyed the decision accordingly. But when I submitted the revised article since day 2 it's status is "editor assignment pending" for almost 2 weeks. ” 7. Oct 14, 2014 · So, do not be surprised if this happens: once the additional review is completed, the status will come back to “Required Reviews Complete. After resubmission, it changed to "Under review" after 12 days, and then "Reviewer request completed" after another 3 days, but it changed to "Under review" again after 7 days. ’ What does this status change mean? Should I consider It’s important to note that “Pending Review” doesn’t necessarily mean the same thing as “Awaiting Review. Jun 14, 2023 · In the Decision stage, the editor-in-chief or the editorial board makes a final decision based on the reviews received. The decision of final acceptance on a manuscript is made by the Co-Editors-in-Chief. Required Reviews Completed. Reviews were completed on time in September. Do I just keep waiting, send another email? What should I do with this frustrating For example, journals can configure status changes that give authors transparency into various stages within the review process that the submission will move through. Jul 18, 2019 · I had submitted a paper to a Springer journal on 29th may 2019. Nov 24, 2021 · After revising and resubmit an article (the first peer review result was "minor revisions"), the status changed after 3 weeks to "Awaiting Decision". The SSA will send you a letter detailing the amount of your benefits, the payment schedule, and any back pay you are entitled to. On this forum I frequently read that the editor-in-chief would usually not overrule / outvote his associate editors. Any application marked as “awaiting decision”, “complete”, etc. ” The former implies that the review process has started but hasn’t been completed yet, while the latter suggests that the review process hasn’t even begun. One month from submission to final decision does seem quick, especially if it seems to have gone through a peer review, as indicated by the ‘Waiting for Reviewers’ Scores’ status. " In the past, I have submitted many articles to several journals and there has always been the "under review" process. Oct 1, 2024 · Note that once completed reviews for your submitted article have been received and are under evaluation by the handling Editor the status may later return to 'Under Review' if additional reviews are sought. Decision in Process The editor has begun to enter the decision into the system, but the author has not yet been notified. See title: what does that mean? I haven't gotten an email or anything from POIs I've talked to. The fact that the status changed from "Required Reviews Completed When a final decision has been made, your submission moves to the ‘ompleted’ menu. The submission status has not changed since the last 3 weeks. Also, please note that peer reviewers are quite busy too. Oct 6, 2016 · After ten more days i. When the decision is made, authors will receive the notification by email and see the decision term in the Revision Required: When the EIC takes the Revision required a decision from the dropdown list, the manuscript proceeds for the authors revision. " with a final Decision. Your application is under consideration and a decision will be made based on the competition for space by 5 March 2020 (if you have not been made an offer by then or your status on the portal has not changed, it means that your application most likely have been Feb 17, 2016 · The current status indicates that the paper has gone through a second round of peer review and is awaiting the editor's final evaluation and decision. It was sent out to one reviewer only and the editor gave a moderate revision decision. Feb 28, 2022 · I have the same issues with Springer right now. One year is a very long time for a paper to be under review, at least in the social sciences. Jul 26, 2024 · Review completed means the review was completed. But the editor has sent your manuscript to another reviewer that's why it's again "awaiting Aug 3, 2021 · “Awaiting final decision” means that now, the manuscript is indeed with the Editor-in-Chief, who is in the process of coming to a decision of acceptance with major/minor revisions (fingers crossed for this!), revise and resubmit, or rejection on the basis of peer review feedback. g. Jun 14, 2023 · The manuscript status can be described as ‘With reviewers’, ‘Under review’, ‘Undergoing peer review’, or ‘Under editorial consideration’. Oct 17, 2024 · Awaiting Decision Approval This status applies to two scenarios: 1) If your submission has not yet entered the Peer Review process, this status means the Editor in Chief is currently assessing your submission to decide whether or not to send it into the Peer Review process. After different status changes, the tracking system has been showing "Reviews completed" since 21/09/2017. Your article has now received the minimum number of reviews required to make a decision. It happens the editors Mar 15, 2016 · Once a paper is submitted to a journal, authors eagerly wait for the editorial decision. For 1 month, the status was "awaiting admin processing. " I am not able to understand the status of my paper. ” Additional Options. Aug 24, 2021 · Hi. Jun 19, 2018 · I submitted my paper to an Elsevier journal. However, till date, I have not received a decision. Aug 11, 2021 · What is the meaning of "decision in process" status? Does "Under Review" mean that the paper has passed the editorial check? What does the status 'under editor evaluation' mean? HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses If your status states FINAL DECISION, it means you have met the minimum requirements for study but have not yet been selected. The status doesn't say what the recommendation was, but it does say it was finalized. For these submissions, the corresponding author can quickly view the most recent decision letter, or the full correspondence. I was wondering about the chances of the manuscript being A few days ago, it was changed to "awaiting reviewer selection". Aug 6, 2016 · Completed Reject: In case the author has made the revisions requested by the peer reviewers and editor, the final decision on the manuscript could be either “accept” or “reject. However, in your case, they decided to review it. The status changed to admin check to under review after one week. ” What does this mean? Jul 30, 2019 · It’s the EiC who will make the final decision. It would be re-reviewed and handled by another editor. The outcome of the review process might be difficult to anticipate based on the status of the article, as the particular meaning of this status varies from journal to journal. The editor has to read the reviews in light of the manuscript and then value the comments and provide a synthesis of the outcome for you. In the Decision stage, the editor-in-chief or the editorial board makes a final decision based on the reviews received. May 8, 2020 · The ‘Decision in Process’ status after the ‘Required Review Completed’ status means that the associate editor (AE), who has been handling your manuscript all this time, has made a decision on your paper based on the peer review comments and your changes, and has now communicated their decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EiC), who will make the final decision. The associate editor (AE) will now make a first decision on the manuscript and share this with you shortly. Editor’s Decision in Progress: A change in status from ‘Required Reviews Completed’ to ‘Under Review’ may signify that the editor has successfully gathered all the necessary reviews from the assigned reviewers. Does this mean that the paper has passed the editorial check and the external reviewer completed? Oct 17, 2024 · Please note that other statuses may fall under this umbrella, such as "Awaiting Reviewer Scores. What does this mean? How many days will it take for a decision of Awaiting Editor Decision. For this reason, the status of your paper may change back Jan 19, 2023 · What does the "awaiting decision" status mean? The "committee review" or "under review" status means we have everything that we need in order to review your application. Something can be both Awaiting Review and Pending Review but once something is in the process of being reviewed it is no longer Awaiting Review but it is still Pending Review Oct 12, 2020 · This refers to the internal check by the journal, for basic aspects such as novelty of the research, quality of the writing, scope match, and adherence to the journal guidelines. So I thought it passed the associate editor's evaluation and now they were looking for reviewers. Does anyone have any idea why the status didn’t Mar 26, 2020 · I submitted a manuscript to a reputed journal using Editorial Manager on February 27, 2020. Oct 1, 2024 · Required Reviews Completed. the article is again out for review and the final decision is pending. Decision notification e-mails and what they mean There are several decisions that authors may receive after submitting their paper to one of the Society’s journals: Reject without review: The Action Editor has rejected the paper without sending it for peer review. While the editorial office replied that the paper was with the editor for a final decision, we have still not heard back from the Jul 8, 2024 · Upon submission to a Sage Journal, your paper enters peer review, where “peers” evaluate the quality of your work. The second update, Awaiting Referee Selection, means that the manuscript has completed the internal check and is now awaiting peer review. ’ The next day, it changed to ‘Awaiting Decision Approval. Sep 6, 2021 · A major revision was submitted to a journal. Even yesterday the status was still "awaiting reviewer selection", but today it was changed to "awaiting EIC decision". I wouldn’t read too much into this status change. While 45 days is not especially long for this stage, the process usually moves faster after the second revision. You will be notified via email if we request any additional documents. The final review can lead to several possible outcomes: Approval: If you meet all the non-medical requirements, your claim will proceed, and you will begin receiving benefits. Make edits to the decision letter text if desired, then click “Send and Commit Decision. Peer review scores have been sent to the editor and the status is awaiting editor decision for almost 4 weeks now. The categories under Slate — the most common app now — without massive customization are “awaiting submission”, “awaiting materials”, and “awaiting decision. ’ If the current reviews conflict with another or are not detailed enough, I may need to seek the opinion of another reviewer. It is not unusual for this stage to take more than a month. Pending decision ; This manuscript status means that the Academic Editor is assessing the peer review process. Then, it changed to ‘Pending Editor prelim decision. Alleviating stress & providing education regarding SSA policies & programs are a core emphasis of the Subreddit. The status of your paper has changed to ‘Required Reviews Completed. Is it a bad sign? Does this mean the article will be rejected? Also known as: with reviewers, with referees, under review, awaiting referee assignment, awaiting referee reports, awaiting reviewer scores, awaiting reviewer invitation , reviewers assigned, manuscript assigned to peer-reviewer/s (NPG) The initial selection of referees is usually comprised in the previous step. ” With “awaiting payment” if you can submit without payment. What does it mean? The article will be handled by new editor? Or the editor is making final decision based on our revised . Required Reviews Completed All necessary reviews have been received by the editorial office (the editor may seek additional reviews in some cases). What does it mean? Jun 15, 2021 · Awaiting Review has the implication that the review has not started yet. It usually takes 1–2 days. If required, the editor may consult the editorial External Reviews Completed, Waiting for Editorial Decision: Some external reviews are in, please wait patiently for the editor to make a decision; Awaiting author revision - see Editor/Author Email log: a decision has been made and we are waiting for a revision / response to reviewer comments from the author (follow the instructions at As Dec 2, 2021 · "Awaiting PE decision" could mean one of two things. If the peer reviewers have chosen to sign their reviews, their names will also appear. Subsequently, the date of the status changed to July 13, while the status remained the same. e around two months from the submission date, I got a mail stating "I have received all the required reviews, which I will now evaluate before making a decision" and the status changed to "Ready for Decision". Last week I sent a gentle reminder to the editor and got no response. Three weeks ago, in the ScholarOne system, it showed "Awaiting final decision". Mine says the same thing (for a different program) and it means that your application is ready for/ currently in final decision review! Reply reply notdanke1337 Mar 10, 2018 · I submitted a manuscript to a journal on September. Any idea about this situation? Does this mean the SE and EIC are making the final decision or they need another reviewer to look at the manuscript? Peer-review I submitted my manuscript to a journal from 1 month ago in scholar one. I have written an email to editor, who replied that the paper is waiting for the editor's decision. Because no one has emailed me, I'm leaning more towards a denial, but I don't know. The manuscript status can be described as ‘With Editor’, ‘With AE’, ‘Under AE Review’, ‘Awaiting decision’, ‘Decision in process’, ‘Decision made’, or ‘Manuscript accepted/rejected’. A manuscript’s progression from submission to decision Jan 10, 2020 · We had submitted a manuscript in June for a special issue. The manuscript has since been under consideration for more than six months now. The article took 5 months and I got decision with minor revision. The status changed to With Editor on February 28 and to Under Review on March 2/3. Jul 1, 2020 · The EiC/EC makes the final decision on the manuscript. In Production. If your manuscript goes from "review completed" to "reviewers assigned", the most probable explanation is that the editor has decided to get more reviewers. Nov 24, 2017 · Once the status changes from "Under review" to "Ready for decision," it implies that the reviews for your paper have come in and the editor can now make a decision on your paper. The time between completion of reviews and to a decision by an editor will vary depending on many factors. However, now in August the status of the manuscript has remained "Awaiting EIC decision" for more than a few days. Now, the status is 'Awaiting EiC Decision. After a few days the status changed to under review and after 5 months the status changed to all essential reviews are complete and presently the status is final decision awaited. On March 24, it changed to Required Reviews Completed, and then, changed to Decision in Process. May 16, 2023 · It is common for the peer review status of a manuscript to change several times before a final decision is reached by the editor. While this might occur, I do not think this is the purpose of peer review and many colleagues Nov 8, 2024 · Possible Outcomes of the Final Review. After subsequent changes in the status (‘With Editor’ and then ‘Under Review’ for 20 days), it showed as ‘Reviews completed’ on September 4. Reject: The paper has been through the peer review process and the It is. The “Decision Started” status implies that peer review for your manuscript has been completed and the journal’s editorial board is in the process of making a decision. 4d: Awaiting author/peer reviewer confirmation: Query regarding revised manuscript, which has been received. After some days, the status changed to 'awaiting reviewer scores', but there is also the status 'awaiting decision' right next to it. Sep 12, 2022 · What does it mean that the status of a submitted major revision is simultaneously 'awaiting reviewer scores' and 'awaiting decision'? Sep 12, 2022 · Does it happen that the editor asks the reviewers to re-review a paper? For about 10 days or so it has been "awaiting final decision" after a few months of under review and then awaiting 6. When a submission has reached the target number of completed reviews, or when a subordinate editor makes a decision ahead of that target: The status changes to Required Reviews Completed. Evaluation recommendation shows that the reviews for your paper are complete and the Associate Editor is evaluating the reviewer suggestions to arrive at a decision about your paper. How long this stage normally takes? is it too early to ask the editor (?) about the status of my paper?” Under Review The assigned editor has initiated the Peer Review process. Sometimes, the editor, after going through the reviews, might feel that an additional review is required. I have submitted an article to a JCR-indexed journal in November and in March, following the request of the journal, I submitted a revised version that contained changes to the introduction and literature review. ' I have heard from seniors that the EiC is only consulted for making acceptance-related decisions and that the AE gives [makes] other decisions. Nov 18, 2020 · Reviews Completed means that the peer review of the manuscript is complete. ” In case Oct 7, 2017 · A manuscript was submitted to one of the journal in springer on 28/04/2017. Assuming your paper's undergone peer review, it could mean that the paper is back from the peer reviewer/s, and after the Associate/Managing Editor (AE/ME) has had a look, they have arrived at a decision and referred their decision to the PE/EIC, who will make the final decision. What does this status mean? Thanks in advance. After one round of flawless revision [needed by the] reviewers, associate editor (AE), and Editor-in-Chief (EIC), [the ‘awaiting’ status seems to be] over. Awaiting Recommendation: The Managing Editor is reviewing the replies from the Editors and deciding where to send the paper. What can this mean? The platform is scholarone. Subsequently, the date of the status changed to 13th July while the status remained the same. If additional reviews are necessary before making a new decision, you may increase the number listed in “# reviews required to make decision” and click “Save” to return to the Select Reviewers step. e. Mar 13, 2022 · 'Awaiting decision' means the required reviews to make a decision were completed. Also, EIC decision could be pending because they may not have picked up the manuscript yet. Pending Review simply implies that the review has not been completed. So, your manuscript is awaiting a final decision. Mar 25, 2023 · The editor-in-chief is the one to take the final decision. The reviewer finished it and submitted it. What does my decision me an? Nov 12, 2020 · The status of my manuscript was ‘Under external review’ for four months. However, yesterday the status reverted back to "Awaiting Reviewer Selection". Apr 12, 2016 · Dear Editage Insights team, I submitted my article 3 months ago to a journal. We would suggest that you wait for another 2 weeks before writing to the journal for an update. An unofficial, casual place for State of California Workers, Union Members, Prospective Employees, and other people interested in State employment to discuss news, events and other items. The status of the paper has since changed from "Under Review" to "Decision Pending", and recently, maybe 4 days ago, the status has changed to "Decision Pending Approval". The Editors may take time to discuss the reviews and may invite more reviewers or assign another editor, returning the submission to an earlier status. fmnywr kkucd ajkie xru kqbnr guqvzeh ovaiq fwmiiv cbmq mxbp zwelo rae jrjwz ewkh pnayb